With more oversea-listed Chinese companies (S-chips) being rapped for accounting irregularities globally and particularly in Singapore, Mr Max Loh, Ernst and Young's (E&Y) new country managing partner for Singapore, says that the firm is strengthening its client acceptance procedures. It is a set of criteria to decide whether to accept or not to accept a prospective client, particularly on those entities en-route for public listing.
Mr Loh, in my opinion, correctly added that improving Chinese companies' corporate governance does not just fall strictly on the shoulder of accounting and auditing profession.
Thus here are the key questions I am asking for this article. Firstly, who are key expertises ie. midwifes, needed to identify, gestate (ie. packaging) and subsequently get them listed (ie. born) at a particular stock exchange? Secondly, what are their responsibilities for pre- and post-delivery?
Besides the accounting and auditing profession, the other midwifes are lawyers, corporate bankers, capital market specialists, the PR specialists and finally the gatekeeper ie. the security exchange. During the good times of S-chips, there are people going around in China talking and identifying companies for incubation and grooming to be listed. Once both parties agree to work towards listing, the rest of midwifes are brought in to do a makeover ie. make it looks good enough to at least last till the first day of being listed.
Once the entity is listed, most of the midwifes' responsibilities expire except for the exchange and auditor. So when S-chip bubbles imploded across the world's exchanges, the minority shareholders ended up with massive losses. When the minority shareholders look for people who should be held accountable, they were stone-walled with the famous punchline ie. "Buyers beware". In the meantime, the midwifes enjoy their bounty. In recent years' as the S-chips' gravy train has come to standstill, many of these midwifes have shifted their operations to more fertile grounds, geographically or to another trade all together.
Should "Buyers beware" be our first and last line of defence? These midwifes were delivering exactly what the investors were craving for ie. to invest in any company with the word "China" in its name. It is observed that no one from Wall Street has been held responsible and prosecuted till today for financial crisis caused by property meltdown in US.
Perhaps the financial market is a stage where every man and woman plays its part, the outcome is the responsibility of no single person but all participants.
The blog is to review how others and Edgar have made/lost their monies. I will attempt to present some business techniques and investment ideas that have been applied in the real world. I will also try to explain the how-to of financial instruments. Caveat emptor. @2006 Edgar Wong. All Rights Reserved.
Showing posts with label News. Show all posts
Showing posts with label News. Show all posts
Sunday, July 03, 2011
Wednesday, June 29, 2011
Lunch is still on for SGX!!
![]() |
| a building which will house many remisiers? |
I have a vague idea that you have spent millions on hardwares and softwares in an attempt to increase capacity and processing speed for transactions. I have yet to see the potential of that upgrades being translated to the bottomline.
You then tried to take away the 90-min lunch break of hundreds of remisiers and supporting staff but failed again. While you may have a target to boost the sagging volume of SGX by lengthening trading hours at the expense of lunch, you have perhaps misunderstand the value of lunch time in Singapore.
Firstly, many of them did not have a proper breakfast, thus lunch break is really something for them to look forward to. (yes.. a cheeky one) Secondly, lunch is perhaps when most of the business is done in this Asian society. Thirdly, is the pre- and post-lunch so overwhelming now that we need to spread the overflowing transactions into that special 90 minutes of the day? I don't think so.
Mr Bocker, you have definitely scored on trying. But let's try to lock in some success! Cheers!
Sunday, June 26, 2011
Is SIA flying out of idea?
By the way its shareholders have structured the company, SIA has a single nature of business ie. to focus on transporting human and cargo. On a more subtle and yet important level, SIA (as also in all govt-linked entities) must represent Singapore as a symbol of excellence with a profitability level to match.
In today's Straits Times, it is reported that SIA is again the 2nd best airline in the world for the last 3 years. SIA even lagged behind in rating for its renowned inflight entertainment system.
SIA has been where it has been over the last 20 years based on a strategy that is deemed impossible as per Michael Porter's Theory of Competitive Advantage. SIA has been able to beat its competitors with innovations and service standards. Innovations and service standards have allowed SIA to achieve highest revenue per passenger delivered at a lowest passenger unit cost. Its passenger unit cost is said to be even lower than that of budget airlines. But the key limiting factor to SIA's growth, in my humble opinion, is the landing rights agreed between two countries. But Airbus A380s helped SIA overcome this limitation by allowing SIA to carry largest number of passengers on the more profitable routes.
Should SIA focus on mergers and acquisition to fuel its growth? SIA does not aim to be largest airline in the world but rather excel in profitability and service quality. But having said that, SIA did attempt some M&A but failed miserably. May I cite ANZ? I am still not sure about the 49% in Virgin but as per SIA's books, the investment has been written off long time ago. We also tried to buy a Chinese airline, an Indian airline.. etc but BLOCKED.
But SIA must continue to be ahead of the curve!! But how?? Under the new CEO, SIA has announced recently that it will enter the budget airline foray officially and wholeheartedly. Could it be a pre-response to AirAsia's massive order placed with Airbus recently? Did SIA hear in the grapevine that AirAsia has a plan to conquer the budget airline world? We will wait and see as the story continues to unfold.
Monday, May 02, 2011
Mapletree Log and Frasers Centrepoint Trust compared
In Business Times dated April 22, the two entities' performance were reported.
Mapletree Logistics Trust
- increase in amount distributable to $37.54 million for quarter ended March 31
- distribution per unit is 1.55cents (1.5 for same quarter last year)
- This represents a yield of 6.8% assuming the share price of 91.5cents and constant distribution per unit over 4 quarters
Frasers Centrepoint Trust
- net quarterly property income dropped 1.3% to $20.1 million
- distribution per unit is 2.07cents (2.06 for same quarter last year
- total distribution for half year to date is 4.02cents (3.97cents a year ago)
- This represents a yield of 5.4% assuming share price of 150cents and constant distribution per unit for remaining 6 months of financial year
Mapletree Logistics Trust
- increase in amount distributable to $37.54 million for quarter ended March 31
- distribution per unit is 1.55cents (1.5 for same quarter last year)
- This represents a yield of 6.8% assuming the share price of 91.5cents and constant distribution per unit over 4 quarters
Frasers Centrepoint Trust
- net quarterly property income dropped 1.3% to $20.1 million
- distribution per unit is 2.07cents (2.06 for same quarter last year
- total distribution for half year to date is 4.02cents (3.97cents a year ago)
- This represents a yield of 5.4% assuming share price of 150cents and constant distribution per unit for remaining 6 months of financial year
Sunday, July 25, 2010
REITable?
it was vacant many years ago
In my Saturday's Business Times, 4 REITs' results were reported. May I summarise the results for quarter ended June 30, 2010 as follows:-
1. CapitaRetail China Trust (CRCT)
Gross revenue - $29.6m (-2.8% compared to Q2 last year)
Net property income - $19.8m
Distribution per unit (DPU) - 2.07cents
Share price - $1.26 (as of Friday's closing)
2. Ascott REIT
Gross revenue - $44.4m (+3% compared to Q2 last year)
Net property income - $11.6m ($11 in Q2 last year)
Distribution per unit (DPU) - 1.87cents (1.79cents in Q2 2009)
Share price - $1.23 (as of Friday's closing)
3. Frasers Centrepoint Trust (FCT)
Gross revenue - $30.7m (+45%)
Net property income - $16.3m (+35% compared to similar quarter last year)
Distribution per unit (DPU) - 2.07cents (1.97cents in similar quarter last year)
Share price - $1.39 (as of Friday's closing)
4. Ascendas India Trust (a-iTrust)
Gross revenue - $30.9m (+4% on year on year basis)
Net property income - $18.9m (+3% on year on year basis)
Distribution per unit (DPU) - 1.66cents (-19% compared to similar quarter last year)
Share price - $0.995 (as of July 22's closing)
P/S - Usual disclaimer apply.
Monday, July 12, 2010
An interesting remark on HK property
Andy Xie, an independent economist said on CNBC today, "HK property is actually more risky than China."
Bernard Lo of CNBC was taken aback and he queried why it is so.
Andy said property owners in Hong Kong, who are hanging on to their property, are hoping for some stupid and wealthy mainlanders to come and pay them millions of dollars for their CONCRETE BOXes.
I am wondering whether the same phenomenon is also happening in Singapore.
Bernard Lo of CNBC was taken aback and he queried why it is so.
Andy said property owners in Hong Kong, who are hanging on to their property, are hoping for some stupid and wealthy mainlanders to come and pay them millions of dollars for their CONCRETE BOXes.
I am wondering whether the same phenomenon is also happening in Singapore.
Saturday, June 05, 2010
General Magnetics - a lesson yet to be learned?
General Magnetics (GM) conducted its first AGM as an unlisted firm last week. Joyce Hooi of Business Times observed that for an unlisted firm's AGM, it was really well attended but with so much outpouring of outrage by its shareholders.
GM was listed 20 years ago as a cassette tape maker, "survived the death of the Walkman age, struggled through the Discman decade as a recordable CD and DVD maker and finally succumbed to the iPod era".
It made losses by the millions since the turn of century and was put on the watchlist in 2008 before being delisted in April this year.
Why are there so much outpouring of outrage by shareholders at this stage? Some shareholders have held on to their shares years after years for the last 10 years despite the annual warning bells of losses being announced. Why lament the delisting?
In fact, they were not outraged by the delisting but rather by the fact the minority shareholders could not force the majority/management to liquidate all remaining assets and distribute the net proceeds to all shareholders. Why would a shareholder buys shares in company and hope the company goes into liquidation?
Towards the end of listed status, the shares had traded so far below net tangible asset value. For those who may have bought at those prices, they are clamouring for the company to be liquidated.
Learning point - Are you holding on to shares of companies, that in recent years, have been making significant losses year after year (eg. Creative)? If so, are you doing anything about it?
Thursday, March 04, 2010
Prudential buying AIG?
Prudential's market capitalisation - about GBP12.3billion (about USD18.5billion)
Purchase price - USD35.50billion
The biggest reason for Prudential to buy - rapid increase in access to a rapidly growing Asia market.
How to pay?
USD$25billions in cash and the rest in Prudential shares
Where to find USD$25billion cash?
- rights issue of USD$21billion ie. issue more shares to existing shareholders
- borrow USD$5billion
Impacts and consequences?
Marcus Barnard said - 3 times increase in the number of shares with only 60-70% increase in contribution from AIG (for now) (thus massive dilution expected for now)
Is Prudential buying at too high a price given the current weak European currencies against USD?
Purchase price - USD35.50billion
The biggest reason for Prudential to buy - rapid increase in access to a rapidly growing Asia market.
How to pay?
USD$25billions in cash and the rest in Prudential shares
Where to find USD$25billion cash?
- rights issue of USD$21billion ie. issue more shares to existing shareholders
- borrow USD$5billion
Impacts and consequences?
Marcus Barnard said - 3 times increase in the number of shares with only 60-70% increase in contribution from AIG (for now) (thus massive dilution expected for now)
Is Prudential buying at too high a price given the current weak European currencies against USD?
Thursday, February 18, 2010
Gold still glitters?

Global demand for gold dropped 11 per cent last year, but the the gold price gained 35 per cent - the biggest annual rise in three decades . Why?
- Just like oil priced in USD and its weakening outlook, the sellers of these commodities have to asked for higher prices in USD to compensate for its weakness.
- It is an alternative perennial store of value against expectations of long-term inflation as the world economy emerges from recession. (Is this still valid?)
- Just pure madness when there are millions of tonnes of gold sitting idle with central banks of the world.
Saturday, January 09, 2010
Singapore, SGX and our neighbours
For year 2010 in Hong Kong / Shanghai / Shenzen
South China Morning Post reported a few days ago that Hong Kong may raise more than HK$300 billion (about SGD60bio) this year through initial public offerings albeit Shanghai and Shenzhen will do better, according to estimates by PWC. PWC forecasts there will be 60 listings this year in Hong Kong. HK$300 billion would represent a 23 per cent increase from last year.
For year 2009 in Hong Kong / Shanghai / Shenzen
- 73 IPOs in Hong Kong last year raised HK$243.7 billion (far exceeding PwC's predictions at the beginning of the year of HK$100 billion).
- Shanghai and Shenzhen bourses raised 185.6 billion yuan (HK$210.9 billion) combined.
For year 2009 in Singapore
- $2.84 billion were raised by the 23 IPOs (about 20 times LESS than Hong Kong)
- $8.29 billion from 17 listed firms delisted, called it a day and went private (due mainly to Chartered Semicon, SPC and CK Tang) (Source - BT Jan 4, 2010)
- Turnover in structured warrants hits 4-year low. Average daily volume last year plunged to $43m from $84m in 2008. (Source - BT Jan 8, 2010)
Countermeasures in motion:-
- new CEO for new ideas?
- Jan 7, 2010 - SGX proposes Special Purpose Acquisitions Company scheme and changing its listing criteria.
We will be watching as the new CEO of SGX gets to work.
South China Morning Post reported a few days ago that Hong Kong may raise more than HK$300 billion (about SGD60bio) this year through initial public offerings albeit Shanghai and Shenzhen will do better, according to estimates by PWC. PWC forecasts there will be 60 listings this year in Hong Kong. HK$300 billion would represent a 23 per cent increase from last year.
For year 2009 in Hong Kong / Shanghai / Shenzen
- 73 IPOs in Hong Kong last year raised HK$243.7 billion (far exceeding PwC's predictions at the beginning of the year of HK$100 billion).
- Shanghai and Shenzhen bourses raised 185.6 billion yuan (HK$210.9 billion) combined.
For year 2009 in Singapore
- $2.84 billion were raised by the 23 IPOs (about 20 times LESS than Hong Kong)
- $8.29 billion from 17 listed firms delisted, called it a day and went private (due mainly to Chartered Semicon, SPC and CK Tang) (Source - BT Jan 4, 2010)
- Turnover in structured warrants hits 4-year low. Average daily volume last year plunged to $43m from $84m in 2008. (Source - BT Jan 8, 2010)
Countermeasures in motion:-
- new CEO for new ideas?
- Jan 7, 2010 - SGX proposes Special Purpose Acquisitions Company scheme and changing its listing criteria.
We will be watching as the new CEO of SGX gets to work.
Monday, August 17, 2009
Do you still trust your bank and banker with your money?
I have just read an article on Business Times entitled "Restoring Trust in Financial Institutions" (FIs) reflecting the views of Mr Simon Newman, Managing Director, AVIVA Singapore.
To restore something means you must have lost it first and then looking to find and put it back. So have we the investing public lost trust in FIs? And the FIs are now trying to restore or regain the public's trust and confidence?
The collapse of structured products amid allegations of massive mis-selling by FIs and their commission-powered sales representatives was the main contributor to that loss of trust.
Can FIs regain that trust of the consumers by simply requiring them to print the sales brochures in all 4 languages (which of course, will be peppered with tons of disclaimers in all 4 languages) and to follow MAS-issued Guidelines on Fair Trading? Mr Newman said FIs need to go beyond merely fulfilling their legal obligations (yes, I agree), (but also) to truly engage consumers and meet their evolving needs in this challenging and volatile economic climate (blah, blah blah). Huh? Is this the panacea to people who have lost millions of dollars of life savings? Let me share with you a parallel example.
The travel industry too was generally in doldrum in the last few months due to the financial crisis. It was later compounded by the outbreak of H1N1. Many who have pre-booked their holidays wanted to cancel and seek refund. Some travel companies are ok to refund but with heavy penalty. The question here - what would you have done if you were running a travel agency?
An industry player opined the industry as a whole should have adopted the position to refund. Otherwise the consequence would be consumers would be more fearful of future early commitment (thus impairing your long term business viability) and prefer last minute self-arranged travels.
Bottomline - When self interest is the foundation of every party's action / decision, the debate will continue. Or given time, the pain will ease and trust will return.
To restore something means you must have lost it first and then looking to find and put it back. So have we the investing public lost trust in FIs? And the FIs are now trying to restore or regain the public's trust and confidence?
The collapse of structured products amid allegations of massive mis-selling by FIs and their commission-powered sales representatives was the main contributor to that loss of trust.
Can FIs regain that trust of the consumers by simply requiring them to print the sales brochures in all 4 languages (which of course, will be peppered with tons of disclaimers in all 4 languages) and to follow MAS-issued Guidelines on Fair Trading? Mr Newman said FIs need to go beyond merely fulfilling their legal obligations (yes, I agree), (but also) to truly engage consumers and meet their evolving needs in this challenging and volatile economic climate (blah, blah blah). Huh? Is this the panacea to people who have lost millions of dollars of life savings? Let me share with you a parallel example.
The travel industry too was generally in doldrum in the last few months due to the financial crisis. It was later compounded by the outbreak of H1N1. Many who have pre-booked their holidays wanted to cancel and seek refund. Some travel companies are ok to refund but with heavy penalty. The question here - what would you have done if you were running a travel agency?
An industry player opined the industry as a whole should have adopted the position to refund. Otherwise the consequence would be consumers would be more fearful of future early commitment (thus impairing your long term business viability) and prefer last minute self-arranged travels.
Bottomline - When self interest is the foundation of every party's action / decision, the debate will continue. Or given time, the pain will ease and trust will return.
Monday, August 10, 2009
Creative Technology - Can see any light yet?
Creative Technology reported a net loss of USD$14 million for its fourth quarter ended June 2009, including a provision of US$12.8 million for potentially unrecoverable loans due from a former subsidiary, compared with a net profit of USD$116.2 million a year ago.
Total loss in FY2009 is USD$137.9 million, compared with net profit of USD$128.2 million in FY2008. The previous year's profit was mainly due to a gain of USD$147.9 million from the sale of Creative's headquarter office and restructuring charges of USD$11.2 million.
I am sure its management knows that it is in need of new ideas that are sustainable. There was a rumour that there could be some sort of a tie up with THX. Whatever it is, the lifeline has to come really soon. Otherwise, the only card left is new Zii platform.
I don't know what it is but I hope for the sake of Singapore's entrepreneurial spirit and Mr Sim's good spirit, the company would turn black soon.
Total loss in FY2009 is USD$137.9 million, compared with net profit of USD$128.2 million in FY2008. The previous year's profit was mainly due to a gain of USD$147.9 million from the sale of Creative's headquarter office and restructuring charges of USD$11.2 million.
I am sure its management knows that it is in need of new ideas that are sustainable. There was a rumour that there could be some sort of a tie up with THX. Whatever it is, the lifeline has to come really soon. Otherwise, the only card left is new Zii platform.
I don't know what it is but I hope for the sake of Singapore's entrepreneurial spirit and Mr Sim's good spirit, the company would turn black soon.
Wednesday, July 22, 2009
SGX welcomes new CEO
Magnus Bocker is replacing Hsieh Fu Hua as chief executive officer of the Singapore Exchange (SGX), the company announced last night.
His profile highlights his fantastic track record in business development ie. putting together small bourses and finally selling the consolidated entity to a big boy. This is in addition to the fact he took his wife's name. (I cannot understand the need for that.)
Anyway back to my intention of this blog piece.. I would like to raise the question as to his competence in the area of control, maintenance, supervisory roles of a stock exchange.
We certainly need a SGX that would play an even hand to its shareholders and yet market friendly to the listed companies and big and small investors (hopefully not always in this order of preference).
His profile highlights his fantastic track record in business development ie. putting together small bourses and finally selling the consolidated entity to a big boy. This is in addition to the fact he took his wife's name. (I cannot understand the need for that.)
Anyway back to my intention of this blog piece.. I would like to raise the question as to his competence in the area of control, maintenance, supervisory roles of a stock exchange.
We certainly need a SGX that would play an even hand to its shareholders and yet market friendly to the listed companies and big and small investors (hopefully not always in this order of preference).
Mr Goodyear, gone So soon?
I just read that Singapore's Temasek Holdings Mr Charles (Chip) Goodyear, the CEO designate, has decided not to become the chief executive of the state investment firm. Reason? Due to differences on certain strategic issues that could not be resolved.
Mr Goodyear had been appointed a member of the Temasek board on February 1, 2009 and CEO-designate, a month later. He resigned on July 21, 2009.
Too short a burn-in period for the candidate to adapt to the economic and political culture and structure of Singapore? Well isn't the candidate supposed to have been selected after an extensive and intensive search for such a high profile and important position ie. managing the wealth of a nation earned with blood and sweat over two or three generations? Or perhaps the portfolio that is supposed to be taken over way too "complex" to digest ie. handover?
Whatever it is - All the bests to you, Mr Goodyear. Perhaps it is just not meant to be.
Mr Goodyear had been appointed a member of the Temasek board on February 1, 2009 and CEO-designate, a month later. He resigned on July 21, 2009.
Too short a burn-in period for the candidate to adapt to the economic and political culture and structure of Singapore? Well isn't the candidate supposed to have been selected after an extensive and intensive search for such a high profile and important position ie. managing the wealth of a nation earned with blood and sweat over two or three generations? Or perhaps the portfolio that is supposed to be taken over way too "complex" to digest ie. handover?
Whatever it is - All the bests to you, Mr Goodyear. Perhaps it is just not meant to be.
Tuesday, July 14, 2009
C K Tang - The Valuation Report
A group of 10 shareholders of CK Tang signed, sealed and delivered a petition to the Singapore Exchange and the Ministry of Finance to protect the interest of the minority shareholders against 89%-majority Tang family's plans to take the company private.
Their main grievance - They are claiming that the flagship 5-storey store (I think, including the basement), which is part of a huge hotel that C K Tang (the listed company) does not own, has been undervalued because the company has not taken redevelopment potential into account.
There are many ways to value an asset. Thus I would be very interested to know how was the valuation done.
How to satisfy the minority shareholders? Based on what I read in the papers today, there are two options.
* Justify your current offer of 83 cents with a vigorously and comprehensively analysed valuation report done by completely independent and competent property professionals, free from any undue influence or opinion from C K Tang's management OR;
* make an offer that at least matches CK Tang's net tangible assets of 93 cents per share as per financial statements dated March 31, 2009 - 10 cents higher than the current offer price of 83 cents.
Will the minority get their report or their money?
P/S - I got no C K Tang shares.
Tuesday, May 26, 2009
C K Tang - U know how to do retail business?
Hi Management of C K Tang,
I saw the news today. You have reported ANOTHER $5.62 million loss for the year ended 31 Mar 2009. The loss was more than double the $2.19 million net loss a year ago.
The recent loss is due to the following:-
- stock writeoff - $7.8 millions
- marketing-related expenses up 8.2% to $21.9 millions
- operating expenses up to $25.7 millions
- depreciation expenses also up by 13% despite relaxing the useful life of some assets from 6 years to 10 years
- Sales how? Only up a miserable 3% to $238 millions
The family - which owns 86.61 per cent of the company - has COINCIDENTALLY offered to buy the remaining shares it does not own at 83 cents per share through a delisting proposal a few weeks before the annoucement of this set of results.
Why do you want to buy over a money losing business year after year? Here are my speculative bits:-
- "Edgar, you are so stupid... it is not retail business that they are after. They are after the last piece of C K Tang building!!!!"
- "Ion, the building across C K Tang, must have aroused their interest."
- "Or is the buying back of shares, an expensive exercise to avoid listening to people like me and the public from querying their retail business management ability."
Saturday, May 16, 2009
Why the need for USD$3 billions loss?
It is reported in various papers today that "Temasek Holdings has cut its losses on Bank of America (BOA). The Singapore investment agency has sold its 3 per cent stake in the bank, resulting in a loss of about US$3 billion as it renews its focus back home and on the region."
Question - Why the need for Temasek to sell down and realised a loss of such a magnitude?
First thing first, you make decision on the merits of individual investment. When you are not short of funds, you don't have to sell before you buy again. You cannot justify the sale and subsequent loss of that magnitude by telling the world that you are "tweaking your portfolio and refocusing back to the region". This is pure crap.
Secondly, it is obvious that the information available to Temasek's management, ie. prior to its decision to systematicly selldown all its Bank of America's stake in Q1 2009, have painted a pessismistic picture of US economy and its banking sector in near term and thus prompted their decision to sell and not wait. They obviously do not believe that BOA's share price would not be any better to mitigate the loss. Recovery is obviously not in sight.
Didn't Temasek's management get any indication from its sources that the global equity markets would run from early May? Or is the current bull run in May an illusion? Or Temasek may be telling us something we don't know or we refuse to believe given the current bull run.
Has Temasek made another "boo boo" by selling too early? Or Temasek may have taken a wise, informed, preventive action to avoid greater future losses?
Only time will tell.
Wednesday, May 13, 2009
C K Tang - Deja Vu again?
Proposal
Tang brothers, now called themselves, Tang UnityThree LLP, are offering to buy all shares they do not own at 83cts. (They offered 65cts per share back in Dec 2006)
Background
This is the 3rd effort to privatise the company.
First time was Oct 2003 at the then offer price of 42cts was voted down.
Second time was in Dec 2006 when they offered 65cts.
Question
Still the same question - Is the current price a fair offer for a stake in a very very very prime real estate albeit in a competitive retail business and rapidly improving hotel business? Why the Tangs want to buy back the shares so badly? What does C K Tang actually own?
If the shareholders had accepted the offer in 2003, a shareholder would have missed on about 7.86% per annum rate of capital appreciation.
Read my previous posting on sum of parts could be worth a lot more.
P/S - I have no C K Tang shares as of today.
Tang brothers, now called themselves, Tang UnityThree LLP, are offering to buy all shares they do not own at 83cts. (They offered 65cts per share back in Dec 2006)
Background
This is the 3rd effort to privatise the company.
First time was Oct 2003 at the then offer price of 42cts was voted down.
Second time was in Dec 2006 when they offered 65cts.
Question
Still the same question - Is the current price a fair offer for a stake in a very very very prime real estate albeit in a competitive retail business and rapidly improving hotel business? Why the Tangs want to buy back the shares so badly? What does C K Tang actually own?
If the shareholders had accepted the offer in 2003, a shareholder would have missed on about 7.86% per annum rate of capital appreciation.
Read my previous posting on sum of parts could be worth a lot more.
P/S - I have no C K Tang shares as of today.
Thursday, February 26, 2009
Ponzi and US Treasury Bills?

News Bite 1
Even the most sophisticated investors put their faith in Bernard Madoff, the New York City financier recently accused of running a $50 billion Ponzi scheme. That breach of trust has damaged the broader markets, Professors Maurice E. Schweitzer and G. Richard Shell say.
News Bite 2
Obama signed off on the record breaking budget.
News Bite 3
Hillary Clinton visited Japan and China in her maiden trip overseas as the new Secretary of State.
Piecing all these events together, I would speculate as follows:-
The US budget deficit needs to be financed by some real US money as the printers are already working overtime trying to meet the delivery to 3 US car manufacturers after doing the AIA's order.
Where to find the real existing US dollars? Oh yes.. the Chinese and the Japanese have plenty of them. So Obama asked Hillary to go borrow some zillions from them in her maiden trip.
If the zillions don't turn up soon, the US government could be accused of doing the next Ponzi thingy with trillions of Treasury bills waiting for their promised interest and redemption?
Never say never. Well at this moment, the above is just Edgar's fertile imagination at work.
Sunday, February 15, 2009
Are managed funds any good?
Are active fees actually yielding any outperformance, let alone absolute returns? A question asked in BT dated Feb 12, 2009.
Based on public data, for a 3-year period to end January, Asia ex-Japan funds:-
the funds' record shows an annualised return of 3.49% among funds, against
2.66% for the index.
Based on the above numbers ==> the index has beaten the fund managers in 2 of 3 categories.
Have you started your soul-searching over the value of active management ie. are the fund managers any good? I have. If you refer to my earlier posting, I am concluding just that. I can't PERSISTENTLY beat the market in the long run.
I won't be surprised that high networth clients are preparing to show fund managers / private bankers the door, replacing their allocations with no-frills index funds.
Should part of sovereign wealth of a nation be in no-frills index funds too?
Based on public data, for a 3-year period to end January, Asia ex-Japan funds:-
- Asia ex-Japan funds lost negative 9% on an annualised basis, compared to
- negative 11% by the MSCI Asia ex- Japan index.
- the funds lost one per cent on an annualised basis, compared to
- the index loss of 0.13%.
the funds' record shows an annualised return of 3.49% among funds, against
2.66% for the index.
Based on the above numbers ==> the index has beaten the fund managers in 2 of 3 categories.
Have you started your soul-searching over the value of active management ie. are the fund managers any good? I have. If you refer to my earlier posting, I am concluding just that. I can't PERSISTENTLY beat the market in the long run.
I won't be surprised that high networth clients are preparing to show fund managers / private bankers the door, replacing their allocations with no-frills index funds.
Should part of sovereign wealth of a nation be in no-frills index funds too?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




.jpg)
.jpg)